Why Your Information Product Will Probably Fail : The Cambodia Cash Paradox

Post image for Why Your Information Product Will Probably Fail : The Cambodia Cash Paradox

“Information products” are the bread and butter of 1st and 2nd wave internet marketers.

You know– ebooks, video series’, pamphlets, newsletters, high pressure sales pages, step-by-step membership sites, all that.

For all the talk of how great info-only business models are, I don’t see a lot of success in-person. I know my sample size is limited, but it got me thinking– maybe making the entrepreneurial leap with an info product is harder than we think.

I get it– info-ambitions are sexy. Did you hear the one about that guy who sells a hundred $97 ebooks a month? Wouldn’t you love to have a business like that? All you gotta do is record a few interviews and put up a sales letter and…

We’ll yeah, and I would love to have this car:

The problem? They’re difficult to get. I’ve done the research.

Same thing with a $100,000 ebook business. Good luck with that.

And I know what you are thinking: what about all those folks with $100,000 ebook businesses? Well, that’s true, there are a bunch of people doing that stuff. But I’m most concerned with identifying strategic approaches to success for bootstrapping entrepreneurs.

If you came to me and told me you were going to quit your job and start selling ebooks, I’d say, sure, you can. But my guess is that you are making it hard on yourself.

Having a successful information product is like dunking an alley-oop. 

It’s an easy shot– if you can jump high enough. It’s not just that info products are the first thing to roll off of the tongue of anyone fresh off the Four Hour Work Week, it’s that they are structurally difficult to sell– and that’s not only because information wants to be free, man (although that’s a huge issue worth of a post itself… it’s reasonable to believe the value of your ebook or DVD series could dramatically drop from year to year).

Here’s two structural problems I’ve seen with bootstrappers starting with information products:

1. Spitballing with results oriented language.

Don’t use “results” language when you should be using “process” language. I often say it in conversation, “you’re confusing the result with the process.” By focusing on the process, you’ll get a better feel for the real costs involved.

Here are some examples:

  • Results (not always useful): Information products are a great way to monetize an audience.
  • Process (more likely to be useful): If you build a huge audience that trusts you over many years of work, they’ll want to buy a broad range of products and solutions from you.
  • Results: Ranking #1 for x key term with a hypothetical 2% opt-in rate will lead to a business with x in sales.
  • Process: Based on our research, SEO seems to be a viable distribution channel for our product line.
  • Results: I’ll build up a group of people who follow me then survey them to see what they want to buy, the product will build itself.
  • Process: If you solve important problems for people over the course of a few years, they’ll eventually start to pay you.
  • Results: I’ll build expert status in this niche buy interviewing other experts and then sell and info product that’ll be gangbusters.
  • Process: Become an expert.

2. Underestimating the effort required : The Cambodia Cash Principle (and Paradox)

  • PRINCIPLE : “Generally, the more appealing the source of income, the more resources you need to expend to get it.”
  • PARADOX: We are attracted to business models with highly leveraged income because we want to free up our time, but we have to spend an extraordinary amont of time (relative to other approaches) in order to develop the type of income that we see as “freeing.” Hopefuls often end up under-estimating the cash runway required to create those cash flows, and fail to make the entrepreneurial switch.

CORRELATE  #1: The more appealing and scalable your product, the more resources it takes to create. 

As a worker, the product you are creating is yourself as an employable person. That might start as you as a cubicle cowboy. That doesn’t take a lot of resources. You’ll probably make a resume, dress up nice, and show up.

As you move up the value chain, your evolution could like like this:–> freelancer –> consultant –> service provider –> creates products –> creates tools –> creates platforms.

The type of of income you create would evolve accordingly:  salary –> contracts –> products –> recurring contracts –> Cambodia cash –> equity or shareholder value –> passive income.

CORRELATE #2: The more hands off your sales process, the more difficult it is to convert leads into sales.

This is a dead horse I love returning to. Most of the conversation in our circles revolves around stuff like SEO, PPC, and creating expert resources. That’s because those are the domain of our beloved passive income businesses. They are, however, not as effective at converting leads into paying customers.

What’s the best way to convert a lead into a sale? Having a personal relationship with them. It evolves from there: personal relationships –> sales meetings –> phone –> Skype –> email –> interviews –> social media –> SEO –> ads –> expert resources.

Ultimately blogging is a better way to reach your target market. What most of us don’t realize at the outset is how resource intensive scalable marketing practices are.

Implications of the Cambodia Cash principle:

  • If you never want to have a job again, you potentially hurt your chances by focusing on “passive income” style businesses at the start.
  • If you aren’t making a living from your website, the most explosive thing you can do is to start talking directly with your visitors.
  • The biggest barrier to developing more appealing types of income from products with scalable marketing is your immediate cash needs. The more time you spend putting food on the table, the less time you spend planting seeds that will take years to come up.
  • If you don’t have a huge and trusting audience of fans or affiliates, give away all your information, including whatever you were planning on hiding behind an opt-in.
  • An info product that provides the majority of the income for a business is much more likely to happen in businesses with developed cash flows, not a bootstrapped start-up situation.

It’s not unlike real life– Cambodia is the last stop on the train. And even when you get there, you’ll probably only want to stay a few weeks.

 

Cheers,
Dan

@TropicalMBA

PS, you can get on my private mailing list by putting your email address in the form below:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • Brad

    Very thought provoking!

  • Elisa Rodriguez

    Thanks for this post Dan :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/vladimir.pashkov Vladimir Pashkov

    Word Dan. I would add personal relationships –> sales meetings –> phone –> Skype->if Skype Sucks than NotVoIP –> email –> interviews –> social media –> SEO –> ads –> expert resources.
    But Very True. Get on the phone. Show some love. Show that you Care!

  • Steven Moody

    You can’t reach cruising altitude without a shit ton of fuel

  • martin

    nice article thank you.

  • Martin

    Im new to this…blogging.  Planning to have my blog… Whats the best way to set up an attractive blog Dan?  I like your blog and website.  What system or serves are you using yourself for blog / website? Martin, Canada.

  • John

    Yet another penny-dropping moment for me when reading one of your articles. I think most folks end up stuck because they read books like the 4HWW and think that it should be easy to setup Cambodia Cash. As one of your posts highlighted (and this article nods the head at) a while ago, the four hour work week is a realistic goal but only after you’ve worked hundred hour work weeks for months getting there. In another of your posts you mentioned ‘you are what you do’ (borrowed from Total Recall?) that suggests you become a good entrepreneur by being a good entrepreneur or at least hanging out with them. The ‘process focus’ you encourage here ties in with that I suppose and facilitates the transition. Moving from employee to beach-bum/millionaire is obviously pretty tricky but there seems to be manageable steps to take a long the way that all serve to reach the end goal.

  • http://www.hendricksendesign.com Taylor Hendricksen

    Ahhhh man, you guys are killing it yet again! I’m loving the perspective I get from this blog. Just when the 4 Hour Kool-Aid becomes a little too sweet you guys spit some fundamental business knowledge that puts everything back in its place. Info products have always been sketchy for me, and I’m amazed how much success people have had with them in the past. Nowadays, like everything else, if everyone is doing (more importantly, everyone trying to TEACH how to do it), it probably won’t be that bunker busting success that you’re dreaming of. Keep up the great work guys!

  • http://tigermuse.com/ Johan Woods

    This is key: “If you never want to have a job again, you potentially hurt your chances
    by focusing on “passive income” style businesses at the start.”

    Develop/use skills first. It’s really basic – become self-employed (more normal terminology than “lifestyle design”) and start working. For me, the entry-level was, and still is, web design (which inherently meets most criteria of location independent business, anyway). Building that up, I can either stay with it or test out new ideas.

    Had I focused on an info product first, or “passive income” type stuff, I would’ve never made it this far – and I have ways to go still.

  • Tasty

    Great post.

    My friend created a short ebook that he and him are selling for 10 dollars as a JV.

    As a 18 year old kid who has nothing to lose and a lot of time, I said hell yeah when he asked me to join because its a learning experience.  I don’t care if I barely make any money from it, the things I learn will help me out eventually.  Then again, I don’t have to put my food on my table anytime soon in the next 4 years.  
    Its been hard, we’ve been building up an email list and have made a very small amount of cash, mainly through forum traffic.  All the points you said above ring true.  To actually have a 100k a year Information product business requires expert status or a wizard like marketing and sales ability.

    Here are the key things I learned-
    1) You need to build trust with an audience first, make them love you before you try to sell them anything.  
    2) Different types of sales pitches for different types of traffic.
    3) Split testing is the shit.
    4) Always experiment, and keep trying new things constantly.
    5) Get the right type of traffic, for example, reddit traffic is pretty much useless.
    6) Build relationships with partners and affiliates(this is very important).  

    And countless other lessons learned along the way.  This stuff’s way harder than it looks, but so is anything worth doing.   

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    I would take this a lot farther than “your information product will probably fail.”  I would say that your business will probably fail even if you’re not focused on “passive income” or 4HWW muses.  Your business will probably fail even if you focus on a service or physical product.

    But…

    That’s no reason to not try.  The rewards (tangible, intangible and perceived) outweigh the risk because there are rewards that even come from business failure such as experience, courage and (assuming you don’t give up) the foundation for your eventual success.

    On another note, the statement from Free: The Future of a Radical Price that information wants to be free is wholly misleading.  All information eventually becomes worthless.  Some information (even ancient) becomes valuable again such as people wanting to homestead and needing to find someone who still knows how to raise chickens or create compost.

    The reality is that plentiful information and news-style information is driven to free by competition.  An example is the Adsense Flippers.  They are giving away the information that their competitors are charging for which gives them a competitive advantage because it supercharges their business model of selling sites.  Eventually, as the competition follows suit to survive in this new market, the “free” information won’t be a selling force anymore.  And even free loses its value.

    Assuming the niche site industry continues for decades (and I think it will) there will be a cycle of paid information, then free information and then paid again in a continuous cycle adapting to market conditions.

    All information works this way.  In some industries the value drops off precipitously such as stock data and others have value that lasts for decades such as old school crafts (woodworking, blacksmithing, etc) before losing value in a market filled with plentiful information.

    Granted the Internet is speeding up this boom and bust cycle and will do so in every nook and cranny, but that doesn’t mean someone shouldn’t build a business from information products.

  • Justin Miramontes

    To be fair to 4HWW; info products have never been mentioned in the book or the blog, have they? It’s always been physical products. It’s the MMO guys who seem to only talk about info products.

  • http://twitter.com/JohnMcIntyre_ John McIntyre

    Ferriss mentions that one of the easiest and best products to create and sell is information. Also, check out this awesome article on his blog - http://www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2011/11/02/the-truth-about-abs-mike-geary/

  • http://www.VacationCareers.com/ Mark Ewing

    I have sold info products for 12 years now, and they are still a great way to start a business.   You can start by selling other peoples products, until you find a successful one (one that sells) then you can create your own based on your findings.  

  • http://www.digitalnomadjourney.com/ Jeff Bronson

    Congrats on your upcoming 100th episode!

    Like most things in life, it all boils down to relationships. Cultivating them, being real and engaged.  Even the mere “consultant” level,  working 20 hours a week actively and living cheaply, is a lot better than the 40-60 hours a week in the grind.

    The possibility of a 100k/yr info business is enough to keep people chasing it. It’s not as tricky as buying a winning lottery ticket, but still a long shot, for full passivity.

     

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    word sir! 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Agreed on your first point there. Your second point about information is interesting. I like that you are making a distinction between “free” and “free with market value.” I never thought of it that way. 

    I’ll have to think about that. If only I could package it and sell it! :) 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Great stuff tasty, you young folks are so much further along that I was. I love what the internet is doing to the type of career cycle I was brought up on — namely, bombing the shit out of it. 

    Split testing– still gotta get more on that. So far I’ve spit tested that my company spends 79 more dollars a month when we have optimizely, and 79 dollars less when we don’t have it :D

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    fair enough. counter point! :D Appreciate you checking out the article Mark. 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Agreed. But pretty awesome! I’d reckon if you work 3-5 years at it full time your chances are decent. Most people can’t even imagine doing that (of course they could for university but…) but if you do, seems like chances are pretty good. 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    WHAT!? :P 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Good stuff John.

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Solid Johan. That solid get valuable stuff done skill set is like a suit of armor. You can take your chances and if you land on your ass you can always make a buck or get a job with somebody who is going to give you a ton of flexibility. No question you’ll be racking in Cambodia cash. Time is the trickiest (bitchiest?) part of the equation.

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Thanks Taylor, appreciate your super kind words here. I don’t want to be a naysayer, just love it when people approach this stuff with some grittier old school strategy rather than “la la la everybody just automate your online riches!” 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    haha Total Recall!!! – that movie is the freaking boss socks!!! :D I was pulling the reference from Aristotle, but I prefer your 80′s Sci Fi as well. I like the point of at least hanging out with entrepreneurs. That’s how it gets done, in my view. 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    YOU GOT IT!!! I take requests :)

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    That’s what she said! 

  • http://www.digitalnomadjourney.com/ Jeff Bronson

    Of course, who wouldn’t want it! :)

    I’ve been at it close to 8 years now, but not on an “info -product” business so to speak.  And because most people can’t imagine doing it, is all the more reason the really motivated ones stand a better chance!!

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    ah indeed! Lot more about this in the future on this blog, I’m assuming :)

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    Get something at WooThemes for free or cheap, host it at Bluehost, mailing list from MailChimp, and then focus all of your energy on helping solve monetizable problems. It’s just like anything else– it’s super hard to make a buck– but it’s totally fun. 

  • http://tigermuse.com/ Johan Woods

     Trying to create a business (and some small ways succeeding) was the best thing that ever happened to me.

    Time is a bitch. I have so many ideas I want to try out (testing, MVP, etc) but SO LITTLE time. And, at the same time, it’s a frustrating 1,000 days. No major traction but occasionally enough where you figure you might as well continue.

    Job w/ flexibility ain’t a bad thing if it’s a stepping stone to other plans.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    I’ve got tons more to say on the topic.  Maybe I should write a blog post.

    Chris Anderson found a way to package Free and sell it.  I think he was wrong on a lot of points, but it was a conversation starter.

  • http://www.bzemic.com/impossibleInstinct/ steve ward

    Great work on the post Dan, the point about people selling $100 dollar ebook is interesting I’ve never seen a $100 ebook I seen a $100 book but not ebook.  Yet it depends on the market your in as well IF you selling a ebook on how to manage your 100 million dollar yacht then a $100 dollar ebook maybe a little low.

    Same thing with a business that does not have a highend back item, I’ve offered a bonus when i had a ebay business for saying picking faster shipping etc. CORRELATE  #1: and CORRELATE  #2: I like these parts of the post because MOST people focus on just one part your selling a 100 dollar ebook when they should be focus on who will pay $100.

    Or they jump around like a jack rabbit from one part of there business to the other without stopping to work on that part of the business. Work the system by Sam Carpenter, makes a good point stop putting out fires and instead work on fire prevention.

    If your system is not working, then take apart the broken parts and figure out how to fix them. Now for the Tim Ferriss point yea I agree I’ve never seen a $100 ebook although he does have a Example of (not sure what just happen everything went bold lol) of a sports supplement where the ebook was free but the supplement was $80. 

    Btw the supplement sold like pancakes yum pancakes

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    PS, I love it when you write blog posts Tim!

    Actually I was writing one last night and stealing your idea. And I thought, I’m glad Tim did all the heavy lifting on this one! :D 

  • http://www.tropicalmba.com Dan

    haha. agreed– yum pancakes FTW! 

Previous post:

Next post: